The Tony Bentley Tankard is awarded for Adjudicators Award.
2000: Entertaining Mr.Sloane by Joe Orton, presented to Brigstowe Theatre Company
2001: Absurd Person Singular by Tom Stoppard, presented to Bam
2002: Bouncers by John Bodber, presented to East Herts Operatic Society
2003: Babes in Arms by Rogers and Hart, presented to Masters Performing Arts College
2004: Of Mice And Men by John Steinbeck, presented to The Barn Theatre Club
2005: Crystal Clear by Phil Young, presented to In Yer Space
2006: Chapter Two by Neil Simon, presented to Hoddesdon Players, Hoddesdon, Herts
2007: Cold Comfort Farm by Paul Doust adapted from the novel by Stella Gibbons, presented to Hertford Dramatic and Operatic Society
2008: Tom Jones by John Osborne, presented to Barn Theatre Club
2009: The Cripple of Inishmaan by Martin McDonagh, presented to Barn Theatre Club, Welwyn Garden City
2010: The Sociable Plover by Tim Whitnall, presented to The Heath Players
2011: The Elephant Man by Pomerance, presented to The Barn Theatre Club
2012: Terra Nova by Ted Tally, presented to Heath Players
2013: Talking Heads by Alan Bennett, presented to Hertford Dramatic & Operatic Society
2014: Awarded to Ken Allford for lighting design for Great Expectations presented by The Company of Players.
2015: Awarded to the Lighting Team of HD&OS for "saving the show"
2016: Awarded to The Company of Players' Hannah Leonard for her portrayal of Hedda Gabler
2017: The two gasps of horror caused by the hammer blows in The Night Alive by Bejou Productions
2018: Awarded to Jonathan James of the Players Theatre (Wales) for his portrayal of Bullshot Crummond
2019: Ben Stanton & Julia Langley for their portrayal of Benjamin and Elaine in White Cobra's production of The Graduate
2022: For the video sequence in the Barn Theatre's production of A Bunch of Amateurs.
2023: Shakespeare in Hollywood by Ken Ludwig, presented to The Company of Players